[Rule] 3SAT to MAXIMUM LENGTH-BOUNDED DISJOINT PATHS

[isPANN]

[zazabap]

Issue Quality Check — Rule

Check	Result	Details
Usefulness	⚠️ Warn	Target problem "Maximum Length-Bounded Disjoint Paths" does not exist in the codebase; cannot assess path overhead
Non-trivial	❌ Fail	No reduction algorithm provided — issue body is empty
Correctness	❌ Fail	No references provided — issue body is empty
Well-written	❌ Fail	Issue body is completely empty; all required sections missing

Overall: 0 passed, 3 failed, 1 warning

---

Usefulness

The source problem "3SAT" maps to KSatisfiability which exists in the codebase. However, the target problem "Maximum Length-Bounded Disjoint Paths" is not currently implemented — pred show does not recognize it. Since the target problem does not exist, this rule cannot be implemented without first adding the target model. Additionally, because the issue body is empty, no overhead information is provided to assess whether this reduction would improve on any existing path.

Non-trivial

Fail. The issue body is completely empty. There is no reduction algorithm described, so it is impossible to assess whether the reduction involves genuine structural transformation or is trivial.

Correctness

Fail. The issue body is completely empty. No references, citations, paper titles, authors, or DOIs are provided. There is nothing to verify.

Well-written

Fail. The issue body is completely empty. All required template sections are missing:

• ❌ Source — not specified in body
• ❌ Target — not specified in body
• ❌ Motivation — missing
• ❌ Reference — missing
• ❌ Reduction Algorithm — missing
• ❌ Size Overhead — missing
• ❌ Validation Method — missing
• ❌ Example — missing

The issue title alone does not provide enough information for implementation or review.

Recommendations

• Fill in all required sections using the issue template for [Rule] issues.
• Add the target problem "Maximum Length-Bounded Disjoint Paths" as a [Model] issue first, since it does not exist in the codebase.
• Provide at least one literature reference for the 3SAT to Maximum Length-Bounded Disjoint Paths reduction.
• Include a complete step-by-step reduction algorithm and a worked example.

[isPANN]

Closing: issue body was empty or incorrect (wrong content). Will re-create with correct content.