Skip to content

[GA close-out sweep] Apply the #1106 verdicts, close the verified-fixed rc-era platform cards, GA-retest the 8 likely-live ones #1150

Description

@hotlong

Filed on maintainer ruling (2026-08-14, verbatim: 「同意」, approving item 6 of the six-item ruling list presented in chat by the objectstack PM seat, session session_018WuTtyckQa1VcXwgd52JpN). Context: the repo is now on @objectstack/* 17.0.0 GA (#1146 / PR #1147, merged 2026-08-14), and all nine objectstack mirror cards for this repo's rc-era platform findings are closed via merged PRs (objectstack-ai/objectstack#5491→PR6684, #5492→6684, #5493→6909, #5494→6153, #5495→6932, #5574→6697, #5591→6343, #7861→7974, #6080→6466). The account-book here has not caught up with the fixes. This card is the catch-up: measurement and bookkeeping only, no feature code.

Mandate

1. Apply the #1106 verdict table (posted on that card 2026-08-11, never applied because the dispatching PM's session ended): close-stale #786; promote #1093, #1086, #853; keep the remaining 30 as graded.

2. Direct-close with a provenance comment each — all verified fixed with rc.2/rc.6 retest readings already recorded on-card, most with an explicit "recommends closing" comment nobody executed: #520, #510, #509, #526, #567, #656, #651, #779. (#525, #524, #521 were closed directly by the PM under the same ruling; #703 is in group 3.)

3. Confirmation probe, then close if green:

4. GA-retest the 8 likely-live (never re-measured since rc.2, or measured-still-broken): #707 (security: allowExport bypass for org-admin), #689 (security-adjacent: full INSERT with values logged at ERROR), #682 (console-chrome i18n cluster — also check the state of its mirror objectstack-ai/objectstack#5407), #680, #701, #691, #986, #1122. For each survivor: file or refresh an objectstack mirror and nominate it for target:v17 on objectstack-ai/objectstack#8667 (Seat A decides nothing — the maintainer approves nominations). For each non-reproducer: close with the reading.

Rules

Measurement first; every close carries its reading (version, probe, result) — no bare closes. No code changes beyond probe scaffolding. Report progress on this card. The v17 bug-focus regime (objectstack-ai/objectstack#8667 / #8668) stays scoped to objectstack + objectui: nothing from this card enters those seats except maintainer-approved mirror nominations from group 4.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    prio:p1Next in line once P0s clearupstream:objectstackBlocked on / caused by the ObjectStack platform — tracked upstream

    Type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions